GGFORUMSGAMING COMMUNITY

THREAD FILE

Reviewing EVERY Max Payne (PC)

@Darran's avatarOPENED BY @DarranJUN 20, 2022, 7:39 AM
14VIEWS2REPLIES
HOSTED BY YOUTUBE · NOT STORED ON GGFORUMSOPEN AT SOURCE ↗
When a man has gone through all the Payne, he can't help but share it with others.
With a great plot to follow, shown with comic graphic novels, realistic gritty surroundings, bullet time-a slow-mo matrix kind of effect- and weapons, revenge and more, MAX PAYNE delivers to the hard core gamers out there. I think it's one of the most under rated video games ever.
I’ve had two quite profound demonstrations this week of how a simple difficulty setting can drastically change your perception of a game. My first was with Fire Emblem; after recalling just how much time I spent raging against the GBA incarnations whenever I lost a character I decided to save myself a lot of bother by turning permadeath off, but this removal of all risk from the equation turned most of the campaign – and especially the end of it – into a braindead steamroller. Fire Emblem just isn’t meant to be played that way, and I gained a new appreciation for just how fundamental that feature is the overall feel and flow of the game. Max Payne 3 has given me the complete opposite experience, however. I dialled the difficulty up to Hard because that tends to be the only way I can get challenge out of these interactive shooting galleries these days, only to have this throw many of the game’s shortcomings into sharp relief. With a more accommodating difficulty setting I probably wouldn’t have noticed; giving me more latitude to make mistakes means the game has more latitude to make mistakes, and I would have breezed through the entire thing and ended up assessing the combat system as “functional” when in fact it’s actually one of the most poorly-designed shooters I’ve ever seen.This shortcoming stems almost solely from Max Payne 3 being a very cinematic game – or rather I should say that they stem from Max Payne 3 being more far concerned with being cinematic than it is with being a game1. Max Payne himself is middle-aged, out of shape and down on his luck, working protection detail for a rich Brazilian family while drinking himself to death, when suddenly armed men attack and kidnap the head honcho’s wife. Max’s attempts to get her back play out almost exactly like a noir-ish version of Man On Fire/Taken/insert other terrible action movie of your choice, with Max touring a variety of seedy and poverty-stricken locales in the course of his “investigation” while monologuing incessantly in the privacy of his own head, because this is a Max Payne game and that’s the defining feature of the series, right? Put enough tortured narration in and anything seems arty; enough blurry jump-cuts of Max drinking yet another shot of whiskey; enough italicised subtitles from the dialogue just in case you’re particularly hard of thinking and don’t get that this is an adult and gritty game; and definitely enough cutscenes. Hours and hours of cutscenes. Cutscenes to hide loading screens. Cutscenes to hide area transitions. Cutscenes to stop you from responding while the bad guys get into their prearranged shooting positions. Cutscenes to make Max drop the good weapons you’ve collected and pick up a simple pistol. Cutscenes for the sake of cutscenes. Maybe 50% of your time spent playing Max Payne 3 will be spent shooting dudes in slow motion. The other 50% will be spent watching a cutscene, because this game wants so desperately to be a film it’s actually kind of pathetic.carsHere’s a funny thing about the cutscenes that I think kind of sums up Max Payne 3’s obsession with appearance over substance. You’ll finish killing a whole bunch of guys, pick up some more ammo, reload your gun and then run along the linear path the level designers have set out for you to the next shooting gallery. When you get there a cutscene will ensue, except because the animators haven’t figured out how to get Max to hold a rifle in these cutscenes he’ll automatically pull out his crappy pistol that more often than not only has one bullet left in the magazine. When the cutscene finishes he’ll still be clutching this peashooter, and in the time it takes you to switch back to the rifle you’ll often get shot in the back by flanking bad guys. It would have been perfectly acceptable to just have him hold a pistol by default in the cutscenes instead of actively taking control away from the player and making them change weapons every couple of minutes. There was one segment in the favelas – I remember this vividly – where a sequence of quick cutscenes over a relatively quiet bit of the level meant that Max pulled out his pistol, I pulled out the rifle, Max pulled out his pistol again, I pulled out the rifle again, and then Max pulled his pistol out for a third time and I started screaming abuse at my monitor. It’s not okay to keep yanking control away from the player like that; I found it deeply, deeply obnoxious and annoying, and it wasn’t even the start of my problems with how the cinematic nature of the game interfered with my actually playing the damn thing.On Hard mode (which is actually the third of five difficulty levels) getting shot just once will take off most of your health, if not put you down completely. One of Max Payne 3’s innovations is to automate the process of chugging painkillers; once your health is reduced to nothing Max will enter bullet time and get the opportunity to kill his attacker. If he does this successfully he’ll collapse to the floor and his health bar will refill at the cost of one set of painkillers. If he doesn’t… well, he dies. It’s a nice idea, and the whole Last Man Standing vibe is certainly very action movie, but unfortunately no-one seems to have given any thought to what happens afterwards. Lying prone means you’re vulnerable, Max is not as spry as he was in the first game – where he’d frog-flip back onto his feet after a shootdodge – and it takes a second or two for him to haul himself back to his feet, meaning that if there’s even one goon left standing you often get put down again because they shoot you while you’re getting up. It’s possible to go through two or three pots of pills in a single shootout (especially with the number of baddies the game throws at you) as Max gets trapped in this never-ending loop of dying, killing, dying, killing and dying again, and so while I don’t think it’s a fundamentally bad idea it’s insistence on prioritising the cinematic (Max collapses to the floor dramatically! But he’s killed the last baddie, so it’s all alright!) over the practical aspects (Oh wait, what if that wasn’t the last baddie) means it really doesn’t work all that well in practice.head (http://scientificgamer.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/head.jpg)
OPEN CHANNEL // THREAD REPLY

ADD TO THE SIGNAL.

Share a reaction, theory, question, discovery, or evidence. Keep it useful and on topic.

POSTING GUARDRAILSUP TO 20,000 CHARACTERS10-MIN GRACE + 5 EDITSEDIT DURING THE FIRST 2 HOURS3 IMAGES / MEMBER / TOPIC1 VIDEO EMBED / POST · NO UPLOADS2 ACTIVE LINKS / MEMBER / TOPIC