Super Mario Bros 1 and 3 and Super Mario World compared to the first 4 Sonic games for the Sega Genesis. In each one of those Mario games, Nintendo pushed themselves creatively to deliver a similar but new experience. Super Mario Bros 3 added way more power ups and included the over world map. The over world map broke up Super Mario Bros’s linearity by allow players to choose their own paths. Super Mario Bros 3 also added soon to be Mario calling cards like mid world dungeons, the Kooplings, and side scrolling levels.But when you look at all the Sonic games, there isn’t that huge change between each game. Sure there might be a new character here or there or shields like the lightening and bubble shield. But those don’t drastically contribute to the gameplay like the new power ups in Super Mario Bros 3. In Sonic, the levels are split up into a few acts where you fight a boss. Sure Sonic 2 added Super Sonic… but how many kids actually were able to obtain all 7 chaos emeralds in a single play through?Now the Sonic games are by no means bad games. I’d say they are some of the best games of the early 90’s. They just don’t show that willingness to change like in Super Mario World. Nintendo even liked shaking up how players cross the goal line at the end of levels. It might be because Sonic is almost forced to focus on “speed” where Mario doesn’t have those constraints. Nintendo is willing to take risks like the inclusion of FLUD. Did it always pay off? Not always. But I can’t help that Sonic’s stagnation contributed to his ultimate failure.
THREAD FILE
Mario beat Sonic
I will pick sonic cuz he can run faster while Mario has the brains to do work. So in my opinion both characters are great according to their perspective.